The recent controversy sparked by Selena Gomez's participation in the film has reignited the debate about cultural representation in cinema. Many critics pointed out the lack of authenticity in the accents and the absence of Mexican actors in a movie set in Mexico, which generated a sense of cultural disconnection. Despite this, the film "Emilia Pérez" offers a visually striking experience.
The cinematography of the film stands out for its careful shots, innovative transitions, and the use of musical elements that give it a particular style, at times perceived as an unintentional comedy. Although the director, being a foreigner, presents his personal vision of Mexico, his approach has been compared to filmmakers like Luis Buñuel and Sergei Eisenstein, who also portrayed aspects of Mexico from an external perspective.
One of the most criticized points was Selena Gomez's Spanish accent, questioned by Eugenio Derbez as "defensible." This detail has generated curiosity among viewers and has opened the debate about authenticity in accent interpretation. "Emilia Pérez" addresses sensitive themes such as drug trafficking, forced disappearances, violence, and gender transition, offering a risky and unique cinematic experience.
The plot of the film revolves around Rita, a lawyer kidnapped by the leader of a Mexican cartel, El Manitas, who seeks her help in faking his death and starting a new life as a woman. The film mixes drama, music, and comedy, exploring complex themes such as drug trafficking and gender identity in Mexico. Despite the criticism, "Emilia Pérez" has stood out at international festivals like Cannes and the Golden Globes, receiving awards and recognition.
The work has divided opinions regarding its boldness in addressing certain topics and has been criticized for perpetuating stereotypes about trans people. Although some LGBTQ+ organizations label it as "retrogressive," the film has been acknowledged for its quality in various awards and is projected to be one of the favorites at the upcoming Oscars. The discussion surrounding "Emilia Pérez" remains alive, inviting the public to form their own opinion by watching it.
