The protection of animals has been elevated to constitutional rank in Mexico, which has been well received by various organizations. However, Arturo Berlanga, director of AnimaNaturalis Mexico, has expressed concern about certain criteria present in the law that could justify practices of animal exploitation, such as bullfighting or cockfighting. In particular, he highlights the ambiguity in the text that leaves room for harmful interpretations.
Berlanga pointed out that the law bases the protection of animals on their nature and their bond with people, which could be used by exploiters to justify activities such as bullfighting. Despite efforts and having submitted a letter backed by 140 organizations, no effective communication has been established with the deputies of the Constitutional Points Commission to address these concerns.
Regarding the issue of bullfighting, Berlanga emphasized that they have always been illegal under the federal legal framework, as they contravene the Mexican Official Standard on humane slaughter methods. Despite court rulings in favor of animal protection, those involved in bullfighting continue to go unpunished, highlighting a problem of impunity and corruption in the justice system.
The director of AnimaNaturalis Mexico also referred to proposals from legislators, such as allowing bloodless bullfighting shows, indicating that these measures are legally and ethically questionable. Berlanga stressed that the torture and exploitation of animals, even without evident bloodshed, remain unacceptable and must be eradicated.
Despite the concerns raised, Berlanga highlighted the importance of addressing violence toward animals through education and emphasized the need for an Animal Protection and Welfare Law that harmonizes all existing state regulations. Although there are concerns about the transitional articles of the law and the lack of communication with the relevant legislators, AnimaNaturalis Mexico will continue to fight to be heard in the Senate of the Republic.
